Christmas Cashew Toffee – guest post

My husband, Craig, makes the best toffee in the whole world.  Almond Roca doesn’t even come close nor anyone else’s.   Although the recipe is from Better Homes and Garden New Cookbook (new meaning published in 1981 – it was a wedding gift), anyone can get it, there is just something different about his.  I think it has something to do with the pot (an old pressure cooker – another wedding gift),a little bit with experience, and a lot with a talented, patient cook.

toffee 3
(Now that’s one mighty piece of toffee!)

Here I will let him tell you about it in his own words.

toffee 4

Years ago I decided I wanted to make myself some toffee.  OK yes, I was willing to share a bit. Toffee is one of my favorite candies and I was determined to learn how to make a good batch.  I have to say, initial attempts were a bit inconsistent with bad thermometers and burning or under cooking.  As the years have passed and my skills improved, sharing our toffee has become part of our Christmas family traditions.  In recent years, I have purchased some nice NordicWare cookie sheets (heavy duty and non stick surface) that don’t get used for anything other than toffee making.  This is a labor of love.  Each batch takes about 25 minutes of fairly constant and increasingly vigorous stirring.

This is slight variation of a double batch of Toffee Butter Crunch from Betty Crocker. With extra commentary. Half the recipe for a smaller sized pan.

Ok, here it is….

**Besides the butter and sugar I do not worry about being too precise with the measurements.

Christmas Cashew Toffee


  • 1 lb (2 cups butter – 4 squares or 1 block – that is what I use)
  • 2 cups sugar
  • 2 tablespoons of light corn syrup
  • 1/3 cup (6 Tbs) of water
  • 1 cup coarsely chopped cashews (I use a small electric food chopper)
  • 1 cup semisweet chocolate chips
  • 1/2 cup finely chopped cashews
  • **Besides the butter and sugar I do not worry about being too precise with the measurements.


  1. In a medium sized heavy saucepan (I use a pressure cooker pot) melt the butter over low to medium heat stirring occasionally to keep from browning.
  2. While the butter is melting lightly spray, grease, or butter a large 12 x 17 cookie sheet. (I use butter)
  3. Hang a candy thermometer on the inside of the pot while cooking, make sure it does not rest on the bottom of the pan.
  4. Once the butter is melted add the sugar, corn syrup, and water.Stir and mix to a sugary goo.
  5. Raise heat to medium or medium-high (the higher the heat the faster you need to be prepared to stir)
  6. Stir using a wooden or non heat-conducting spoon at a slow pace taking brief breaks until the temp is approximately 225 degrees. (The only reason for stirring slow is to save your energy for the latter stages)
  7. Above 225 degrees, stir constantly and progressively more quickly to minimize scorching. (The hotter the stove top, the more prone the mix is to burn)
  8. After the heat rises above 270 degrees watch carefully because it will begin to heat up more quickly.
  9. Toward the end, you will feel like both the toffee and your arms are burning. (20-30 minutes) By now you will have switched hands several times. You will want to stop. Keep going! Toward this end it will have turned a dark golden brown and may be smoking a bit.
  10. After the temperature passes 290 degrees, remove from heat, stir in the coarse nuts, and remove the thermometer. (A little burning on the bottom of the pan is normal. A lot of burning may not ruin it, but might add a slightly bitter taste making it more suitable to ice cream topping. Well yes, you can over cook and burn it if you try hard and don’t stir enough.)
  11. Pour entire mixture onto the cookie sheet, spreading evenly to the edges with the stirring spoon.
  12. After cooling slightly, (5-10 minutes) spread the chocolate chips evenly over the surface. Wait a few minutes to allow the chips to melt. (If you allowed it to cool too much a hair dryer can assist in melting the chips.) Avoid smearing the chips all the way to the edge of the pan to simplify cleaning.
  13. Once the chocolate is spread, sprinkle the finely chopped nuts across the surface. (Optionally, press surface with a clean dry hand to assure nuts are stuck tight.)
Schema/Recipe SEO Data Markup by ZipList Recipe Plugin

I usually cover with wax paper or paper towel and let is sit overnight to cool and harden. In a pinch, I have used the freezer for faster cooling.
Use a stiff knife to chip into the toffee and subsequently a spatula to lift big pieces from the pan. Break toffee into bite sized pieces.
The biggest problem most people have is over or undercooking.

Enjoy this delicious toffee Christmas treat!



  1. Wow – that looks delicious! Toffee is sooo yummy!

  2. Yum! Toffee is my favorite treat! I’ll have to try this recipe!

    1. Ellen Garrett · · Reply

      I hope it works well for you. The recipe is great but does take patience and love and lots of stirring.

  3. Yum!! That sounds sooo good! Thanks for sharing your recipe!

    1. Ellen Garrett · · Reply

      Let us know how it works for you. We love it, but it really is a labor of love from Craig.

  4. This is my all time favorite Christmas treat, hands down! Thanks for the recipe. I have never tried making it myself and now I have no excuse :) Pinning!

  5. Oh. My. YUM!! This looks like something I can gobble up in no time.

    1. It is so good and super easy to gobble up quickly. Craig can’t seem to make enough for all our friends because the family eats more than our fair share. Good luck.

  6. My husband LOVES toffee so I’m going to give this a try tomorrow, I’ve cleared my day…lol

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: