Go Back
A Fudge Stripe cookie decorated to look like a Pilgrim Hat with a Peanut butter cup on top.
Print Recipe
No ratings yet

Pilgrim Hat Cookies

These Pilgrims hats are so cute and perfect for Thanksgiving, it would even be fun to have the kids make their own.
Prep Time20 mins
Total Time20 mins


  • 1 19.75 oz package Reeses Peanut Butter Cup Miniatures
  • candy corn
  • 1/2 cup orange frosting
  • 11.5 oz package fudge striped cookies


  • Unwrap the Reeses Cups, and set them aside.
  • Cut the yellow top of your candy corn pieces, and set them aside. You can use the orange/white portions for later, or discard.
  • Scoop the frosting into a ziplock bag or piping bag with a round tip attached.
  • Squeeze orange frosting onto the top of a Reese's cup.
  • Place the Reese's cup upside down onto the center of a Fudge Stripe cookie.
  • Place a yellow candy corn piece into the frosting for the hat's buckle.
  • Let the frosting set, or enjoy the cookies immediately.